Future Fedoras: Detective Sci-Fi

Hard boiled detectives aren’t only found in the pulps and can also be found on many a planet in the science fiction galaxy and fantasy universes. The uniform changes slightly between gumshoes, but the quick patter, ability to take a punch, and cynical streak of unbendable morality is consistent, even if it is in a galaxy far, far, away.

It’s been said that mystery and sci- fi/fantasy genres couldn’t be blended because you would naturally have situations or weapons that the reader had no reference to. The locked room mystery would be solved in 2 pages by the introduction of the Personal Transporter Pad, or the activated Heart Crush Spell of the Ancient Djooneormihntz. Anyways, they can be melded, and well.

Here are a few of my favorite sleuths:
John Justin Mallory

Saddled with a ninety pound cat variant that only loves him when he’s promised her food, a magic mirror that plays dirty movies, and a partner that’s a former big game hunter with gryphon and unicorn heads mounted on her walls, John Justin Mallory is not in Manhattan any more. At least, not in his Manhattan. This one is full of vampires, wizards, goblins, and an Evil Incarnate with a moral streak. And it’s just those similarities that are making his adjustment easy. From tracking down a prize-winning show Chimera (Fluffy) before the Eastminster pet show, or locating a murderous vampire just over from the old country, Mallory does it all with wit and amazing patience. Mallory first appeared in Mike Resnick’s 1987 novel Stalking the Unicorn and, other than several short stories, didn’t show up in long form again until 2008’s Stalking the Vampire and 2009’s Stalking the Dragon.

Garrett, P.I.

When your roommate has been dead for 400 years (technically), your best friend is a vegetarian half-dark-elf killer, your elderly houseman is trying to hook you up with one of his spinster nieces (who may have ogre somewhere in their family tree), and the local Kingpin knows your name and isn’t sure if he likes you, then things like centaurs, elves, trolls, gods, or magic don’t much bother you. They certainly don’t bother Garrett, P.I., an ex-Marine and current hard boiled detective of the old style who wisecracks his way through saving stray damsels in distress to ridding the local theater of bugs. Garrett’s home town of Tunfaire is an eye-opener, flinging back the curtain on the seamy side of creatures we thought we knew; Unicorns gone bad (really, really bad), the bitchy side of Elven women, giant/troll offspring (grolls), professional thugs that scrupulously keep their word, and other rather unbelievable twists of character. Sweet Silver Blues is the first of a dozen books (soon to be a baker’s dozen) in the Garrett, P.I. series by Glen Cook.

Mack Megaton

A near-indestructible battle robot, Mack Megaton was built by an evil genius bent on world domination. That gig fell through when the mastermind landed in the slammer, so he became a cab driver to pay his electric bill. Because he has “The Glitch” of self-awareness he’s on probation to becoming a full citizen and in therapy. When the human family next door disappears, Mack knows something’s amiss and, using basic detective techniques he follows a bare (metal) -knuckled trail through (alien) crime syndicates, is dogged by a (3-foot tall and furry) police detective, is vamped by a (child prodigy genius) bombshell with great gams, and picks up a (mutant ape) sidekick. Unfortunately Mack inhabits only one book, The Automatic Detective by A. Lee Martinez.

These are only a few of the many sci-fi sherlocks out there, but I’ll leave it to you to sleuth the rest of ’em out.

~Jay F., Central Library

6 responses to “Future Fedoras: Detective Sci-Fi”

  1. That Garrett PI series sounds hilarious – it’s definitely going on my reading list.

    For gangster-inspired sci-fi, I also really like Vernor Vinge’s short story / novella, The Ungoverned.

  2. I LOVE these kinds of hybrids. Another one – though it is kind of out there, but it is shelved in our SF section – is Steve Ayelett’s “Crime Studio.” Highly original. Then of course there are those great Future noirs by Richard Morgan, starting with “Altered Carbon.” And Douglas Adam’s tongue in cheek take on all this, Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency, and The Long Dark Teatime of the Soul. Good stuff, Jay.

  3. Lady Readsalot

    I love both genres. I’ll go out on a bit of a limb here to highly recommend the latest really memorable hybrid I’ve read: China Mieville’s book The City and The City.

    It is a fairly standard tho well-plotted crime mystery (the nicely developed main character is a hard-bitten police detective rather than a PI (don’t remember if there was a fedora but can visualize him with one; I do hope he’s in another book someday ), but it is the setting that is so weird & wonderful. I will need to read it a couple more times to decide if it is really truly SF: there is a fine line between a definition of SF as “cannot exist here & now” and “an extrapolation of here & now taken to some extreme”. This book takes place on our current Earth, it is very believable, but, well, um, …. not.

    The setting is so intense & multi-layered that I do know I will have a delightful re-read (I’m actually putting it off in anticipation), & meanwhile I would include it your criteria.

    PS: no unicorns, no vampires. This is reality …. maybe.

  4. ::scribbling furiously:: Have a few more books on my to read list now.

    Audrey:I like the way Vinge writes, haven’t run across that one yet. The Garrett books are wonderful popcorn reading. I got the feeling that Tunfaire was just down the road from Pratchett’s Ankh-Morpork.

    David: Have read Altered Carbon and Kovacs shows up in a few more most excellent novels worth a read. What I find about Aylett’s book sounds interesting. Enjoy satire alot.

    Lady: The City and The City certainly looks like something to pick up. Dimensional physics vs human perception is a hard concept to write well and believably. You touch on something that I wonder about in general; is it harder to write the sci-fi detective as a Police Detective vs a PI? When you write from a Police perspective there comes restrictions on actions in a legal framework that the author must define much clearer than for a PI. (I had a bit of problem on a story many moons ago when I had to build a “legal” code from the ground up just to find that it would negate the protagonist’s ability to solve the crime as a ‘police officer’)

    A couple of my more serious favorites (sorry Captain Vimes) are Harry Dresden, Rusch’s Miles Flint (retrieval artist novels) and Frank Compton from Timothy Zahn’s Night Train to Rigel (plus 2 more books). Been a fan of Zahn’s since the Cobra series and the Compton novels have a bit of the same protagonist self-examination of his impact on society.

    Thanks much for the comments!

    jay

  5. A series I recently discovered was by Charlie Huston. His Joe Pitt casebooks, starting with Already Dead, plunge the reader into a vampire- and zombie-infested New York. His vampire society is structured into a bunch of competing clans that are somewhat Mafia-like and constantly warring with each other. Pitt, being unallied with any of the clans, is a free agent who frequently gets caught up in dangerous situations, alternately working for and aganist them. The books are a great read for anyone looking for a noirish antihero and an original, immersive atmosphere.

  6. Lyon: You’de probably like the Halflife Chronicles series by Wm Mark Simmons. (stumbled on them scoping the shelves one day) Also has vamps, weres, and other various denizens of lore that are organized into geographic demesnes that have very precarious and fluid truces or alliances. Vampirism is apparently a 2-virus infection and the main character (Chris Csejthe) was infected with only one of them and becomes quite powerful. The story is pretty much his investigating how he became infected mixed with trying to stay alive and love problems with a werewolf. Great wit! Any book that can somehow write in something about Rasputin’s naughty bits has got to be good, right?

    Series begins with “One Foot in the Grave.

Leave a Reply to Audrey BCancel reply

Discover more from Shelf Talk

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading