Christmas Music for Grinches

Ok, I’ll admit it: I am a Grinch. Christmas is my least favorite holiday. Why do I despise Christmas? Well, one reason is the music. Most Christmas music is cheesy commercial schlock that gets stuck in your head and torments you for days on end. Worst of all, starting on Black Friday, it is virtually inescapable every time you step into a store or public place. Having worked in retail for 4+ years, I know how soul-killing it can be to hear the monotonous strains of “The Little Drummer Boy” for the fifth time in an hour. Thankfully, I have also discovered some Christmas albums that don’t make me want to plug my ears with wax until January 1st. Check ‘em out, fellow Grinches!

A Christmas Gift For You From Phil Spector. Hands down the best collection of rockin’ Xmas tunes ever recorded. Darlene Love’s heartfelt version of “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” never fails to give me chills.

A John Waters Christmas. From the King of Trash Cinema comes a compilation of kitschy holiday songs unlike any you’ve ever heard. Highlights include: “Fat Daddy,” “Sleigh Bells, Reindeer and Snow,” and my personal favorite, “Here Comes Fatty Claus,” which should be the national anthem for Grinches everywhere (WARNING: this song may not be appropriate for all audiences. But hey, it’s John Waters, what do you expect?).

Three Suites by Duke Ellington.  Ellington’s delightfully jazzy adaptation of Tchaikovsky’s “Nutcracker Suite” breathes new life into a seasonal standard.

Gling-Gló by Björk. Ok, I know that this record is technically not a holiday album, but at my old bookstore, it was always in heavy rotation during the Christmas season. Besides, I’m pretty sure that Björk is secretly an elf. And here she sings jazz standards in Icelandic. If that doesn’t get you in the holiday spirit, nothing will.

Go Tell It on the Mountain by The Blind Boys of Alabama. Rollicking blues-tinged and gospel-inflected versions of traditional Christmas carols and popular holiday songs make this album a fun listen.

Handel’s Messiah. I can’t really hear the “Hallelujah” chorus anymore, thanks to it being so overplayed, but I always get a kick out of “All we like sheep” (who doesn’t?) and “He was despised.” Hearing this work live can be an incredible experience; the Seattle Symphony will be performing it from December 16th through December 19th.

All you Grinches and non-Grinches out there, it’s your turn now. Leave a comment and tell us about your favorite holiday album(s)!

15 responses to “Christmas Music for Grinches”

  1. Great post, Abby! I’m giddy for Christmas music, and hearing Doris Day sing “Silver Bells” makes me want to skip down Seattle’s Fifth Avenue at night when all the trees are lit with little white lights. My favorite LPs are those Goodyear/Firestone compilations people bought at gas stations in the early 1960s, and the BEST of all is Goodyear: Great Songs of Christmas by Great Artists of Our Time, Album 5 with Andy Williams, Sammy Davis Jr., Maurice Chevalier, Doris Day and Diahann Carroll. The CDs I probably play the most during December, though, are The Roches’ We Three Kings (skipping their annoying version of “Frosty”) and Leon Redbone’s Christmas Island (also skipping occasional songs). But that Goodyear Album 5? I don’t need to skip any songs.

  2. I always play Low’s “Christmas” when I decorate the tree. Even if their version of “Little Drummer Boy” was hijacked by The Gap, I still love it.

  3. I love A John Water’s Christmas. Santa Claus is a black man!

  4. Mojo Nixon and the Toadliquors “Horny Holidays”. Best version of “Good King Wenceslas” ever.

  5. Tchaikovsky’s The Nutcracker always does it for me. It makes me nostalgic for my childhood ballerina days. Every year during the holidays our little group performed The Nutcracker; the 5-7 year olds always do “Tea” while the 7-9 year olds perform “Coffee”. I couldn’t wait until I turned 10 – the 10-12 year olds dance the “Trepak”. The music and dancing were so exciting! In fact, if you are in Hanalei, on the island of Kauai, during the month of December you can still see the same performance!

  6. I love “Here Comes Fatty Claus!” I’ll listen the the Waitresses’ “Christmas Wrapping” any time of year.

    I worked in a mall record store for several years and the X-mas music was the worst. The year Jingle Cats came out just about killed me.

  7. How could you forget “Dr Demento presents the greatest Christmas Novelty CD of All Time” 3 holds right now! with hits like
    All I want for Christmas is my Two Front Teeth
    Jingle Bells barked by Dogs
    Christmas Dragnet

    Co’mon!

  8. Great post, Abby! I too am a Grinch.

  9. Jason Lee

    My first year working in a music store back in 1994, I heard the best XMAS CD but still have not found it on shelves. It was the Tales from the Crypt Christmas Album. With tidbits from the CryptKeeper between songs.

  10. I could listen to “Songs for Christmas” by Sufjan Stevens all year long.

  11. Checked “Like” 🙂 Thanks for a great post, Abby. Your post made me smile. I’m definitely going to try to check out some of these CDs.

    p.s: I’m also a Grinch

  12. I am very much not a Grinch, at least if crying over the yearly dusting off of Amahl and the Night Visitors is any indication. One recording that I just love this time of year is Christmas in Russia – in which choirs from religious orders sing Russian and Ukranian carols. There is one track on here of “Silent Night” sung by a pair of nuns that will melt the Grinchiest of hearts – it is chillingly beautiful.

  13. http://seattle.bibliocommons.com/item/show/2689089030_joy_to_the_world_(cd)

    If I’m feeling Grinchy during the holiday season, I can count on good music to bring me out of my fog and funk. This new Pink Martini album is one of the best i’ve heard in years. The Portland band goes around the world to find songs and singers – White Christmas in Japanese, Auld Lang Syne with a Brazilian beat and rhythm section, a great Hannukah song I’d never heard before, and more. This one’s so good you may want your own copy.

  14. Great post Abby! And David, thank you, thank you, thank you kindly for your comments. I’m one of those proud non-Grinches. Sure, there’s a ton of crummy Christmas music out there but heck, that’s true of any genre!
    Some of my favorites are Doris Day’s sultry “Let It Snow” http://seattle.bibliocommons.com/item/show/2457508030_personal_christmas_collection and the whole album of Harry Belafonte’s “To Wish You a Merry Christmas,” but particularly his version of “I Heard the Bells on Christmas Day.” Outstanding!
    http://seattle.bibliocommons.com/item/show/1780353030_to_wish_you_a_merry_christmas

  15. Abby… my advice when you’re feeling Grinchy…
    dust off The Nutcracker Ballet and dance to The Waltz of the Flowers.
    Works every time.

Leave a Reply to MindyCancel reply

Discover more from Shelf Talk

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading