Why are you reading that book?

After you read Pierre Bayard’s book How to Talk About Books You Haven’t Read, he will lead you into questions like this. A bestselling author in France, Bayard claims he doesn’t care much for reading. One of his main points is that one can have an intellectual conversation about literary classics, such as Macbeth and Crime and Punishment, without ever reading the book at all. In fact, he finds it completely unnecessary to read any book in its entirety. Not only is there not enough time to read the never-ending list of unread books, but the process of reading is also a process of erasure. Bayard makes this argument through Robert Musil’s librarian, who is obsessed with books and overwhelmed by the infinite library he will never live long enough to get through:

'Robert Musil's librarian
Robert Musil

 “Every time we read a book, we begin the process of forgetting it details of plot or character vanish, even the book’s general   outlines blur, sometimes we forget having read it at all. Conversely, it is not necessary to have read a book in its entirety, or even at all, to know a great deal about it. It’s more important to know about a book’s role in our collective library than its details.” (Think Jane Austen and her reemergence of popularity today).

So, don’t feel obligated to finish a book you started, guilty you didn’t read the book club pick, or socially accountable to catch up on classics you forgot, or never read. Read for the simple pleasure of reading. Whether that is to relax, satisfy your curiosity, escape pressures of daily life, educate yourself, or gain a different perspective. When books have made a deep impression on us, Bayard says, “We are the sum of these accumulated books”.

If you love reading and are interested in the reader’s  role then you will enjoy Bayard’s paradoxical, witty and thought-provoking views.

Here is a list of books I took home from the library and intend on reading entirely:

  • The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield: An amateur biographer interviews a famous fiction author to get the truth out of her.
  • The Clan of the Cave Bear by Jean M. Auel: A young girl from an advanced race tries to fit in with the clan bound to tradition.
  • The Housekeeper and the Professor by Yoko Ogawa: A housekeeper and her son build an unlikely friendship with a mathematician whose memory lasts only 80 minutes and is obsessed with prime numbers.  

Here is a list of books I never finished reading, but appreciate as a story:

  • Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare: I agree that it’s a good tragic love story, but I struggled to read the Old English.
  • Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen: When all the hype about Jane Austen surfaced I decided to give it a try, but with my limited vocabulary I couldn’t enjoy it (I think I’ll watch the movie). 
  • The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck: I really enjoyed two of this author’s books that we were required to read for high school, but this book was way too long for me to finish. (However, I did like the play and there was a really cool rain scene reenacted on the stage).     ~ Renee, Northgate Branch

2 responses to “Why are you reading that book?”

  1. Thanks for this post and for making me and others feel okay about putting down an unfinished bk. Another challenge that I find is not remembering details of bks that I really enjoyed yearsssss ago – I am trying to be kind to myself about that.

  2. WOOT!

Leave a Reply to Kara P.Cancel reply

Discover more from Shelf Talk

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading